In the U.S., Queen Is Mourned by Those Who Were Never Her Subjects – The New York Times

Share Article

Send any friend a story
As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Anyone can read what you share.
Nicholas Fandos and
The mourners began pouring in to Myers of Keswick, a small British grocery store in Manhattan, on Thursday morning even before Elizabeth II’s death, on the hunt for tea towels, royal memorabilia, Cornish pasties and other small tokens of Britishness to mark a moment in history.
But when the news that she had died finally arrived via telephone, Irene Donnolly, a shopkeeper, knew just what to do: After listening to “God Save the Queen” in the shop’s tiny kitchen, she pulled a framed portrait of the queen off the wall and placed it carefully in the window, nestled in Union Jack bunting.
“It’s the end of an era,” said Ms. Donnolly, who has worked at the shop since she moved to New York from Ireland two decades ago. “I can’t even speak.”
England’s longest-reigning monarch was mourned across the world on Thursday as an unrivaled source of constancy, whose reign helped shape the modern world order and Britain’s colonial legacy. But in few places outside the United Kingdom was the outpouring so striking as in the United States, a faraway former British colony she never ruled and only occasionally visited but still managed to transfix, in one way or another, for generations.
From Independence Hall in Philadelphia to the seaside California home of Prince Harry, the queen’s grandson, Americans crowed about the “special relationship” between the two nations (a favorite term of American and British politicians), gawked at the rarefied world of wealth and celebrity that surrounded her (tens of millions of Americans tuned in for Harry’s wedding to the American actor Meghan Markle) and marveled at her sheer longevity.
Though the queen was never actually a part of it, few people were firmer fixtures in American life for longer. In 70 years on the job, Elizabeth served alongside 14 American presidents going back to Harry Truman, sitting on the throne across the Atlantic for almost a third of the history of the United States as an independent nation.
“Americans have a craving for celebrity, an admiration for wealth and an interest, I think, in figures who step out of politics,” said Maya Jasanoff, a Harvard historian who studies the British Empire, noting that the queen largely remained above the passing political fray. “The royal family has managed to fill that yearning for Americans through decades.”
“Let it not be forgotten that early in the history of the American republic, there were some conversations about whether George Washington ought to be a monarch,” she added in an interview.
In modern Washington, where partisan forces are once again testing the foundations of the American republican experiment, Republicans and Democrats briefly set aside white-hot domestic disputes to share their admiration. One of them, President Biden, who first met the queen in 1982, called her “a stateswoman of unmatched dignity and constancy.” Another, former President Donald J. Trump, took a more personal view: “What a grand and beautiful lady she was,” he said.
Both parties promised friendship and support for her son and successor, King Charles III, whose government has been working with the Biden administration to orchestrate an international response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
At the marble Capitol, which still bears scars from British ransacking during the War of 1812, the House of Representatives lowered flags to half-staff and planned to pass a bereavement resolution next Tuesday, then adjourn to honor the queen’s memory, as it did after the death of her father, George VI, in 1952. Elizabeth was the first and only British monarch to address a joint meeting of Congress in 1991.
Miles away, outside the British embassy, tributes were left in words and flowers Thursday afternoon.
Meg Massey, 36, a nonfiction writer who stopped by, said the monarchy’s “colonialist history” was fair game for criticism. But as an American long fascinated by the royal family, she said, “we get to watch the drama without having to pay for it.”
She said that Elizabeth had promised as a young woman to serve her country for the rest of her life, and she did. “You can also honor and celebrate that,” she added.
That service did not inspire solely admiration. Though she ruled through the gradual shrinking of the British Empire and the independence of former colonies, for some Americans, Elizabeth remained the symbol of British imperialism. Many other Americans see the monarchy as an anachronistic and costly institution.
“I have no reason to cast aspersions on the queen herself as a person, but the institution was increasingly one that was bound up in the 19th and into the 20th centuries with consolidation of empire,” Ms. Jasanoff said.
Tributes poured forth from unexpected corners of the country — some that felt worlds away from the stately confines of Balmoral Castle in Scotland, where the queen spent her final days.
The University of Maryland Terrapins shared an image of a commemorative program from October 1957, when Elizabeth attended an American football game in College Park on her first state visit to the United States.
At Madame Tussauds, the wax museum in Times Square modeled after the London original, the ninth-floor display where visitors can usually “sip tea” with the queen was replaced with a wooden table and guest book for condolences.
A British-themed pub in downtown Philadelphia planned to serve the queen’s favorite chocolate dessert. Nearby, at Independence Hall in Philadelphia, David Lubin, a guide escorting tourists from Israel, pointed to her endurance and adherence to the rules.
“She was a strong woman,” said Mr. Lubin, 64. “She kept the tradition, and she didn’t bend, but she respected the democracy.”
Across the country, in Montecito, Calif., the sun-drenched coastal enclave where Prince Harry and Ms. Markle relocated two years ago, Elena Hancock, 26, said the couple were often the source of “hot gossip.” But not the queen.
An avid viewer of “The Crown,” an award-winning Netflix series about Elizabeth’s life, Ms. Hancock said she had viewed the queen as timeless.
“She’s kind of one of those people you think is always going to be there,” she said.
As for the newest occupant of the throne, Elizabeth’s son, King Charles III, some Americans were less than effusive.
Jennifer Myers-Pulidore, the owner of Myers of Keswick in Manhattan who was born in America to British parents, laughed out loud when asked about Charles, shifting the conversation to his beloved late ex-wife.
“I loved Princess Diana, and that is all I will say,” she smiled. “I’ll leave it at that.”
Reporting was contributed by Jon Hurdle in Philadelphia, Sarah Maslin Nir in New York, Ariel Sabar in Washington, Jill Cowan in Santa Monica, Calif., and Jackie Sedley in Montecito, Calif.


You might also like

Surviving 2nd wave of corona

Surviving The 2nd Wave of Corona

‘This too shall pass away’ this famous Persian adage seems to be defeating us again and again in the case of COVID-19. Despite every effort